.:: replacementdocs ::The original web archive of game manuals ::
 
::.
Main Menu
Welcome
Username:

Password:


Remember me

[ ]
[ ]
[ ]
Search replacementdocs
Top Contributors
Author Requests
1. Vimm  465198  (5.4%)
2. afc  411752  (4.8%)
3. SimonU  334715  (3.9%)
4. aiguo  303107  (3.5%)
5. drewbar  256558  (3.0%)
6. Electric Fungus  195109  (2.3%)
7. marklodi  194382  (2.3%)
8. Paul  185063  (2.2%)
9. dave13  169691  (2.0%)
10. Lucky Eddie  152896  (1.8%)
 
Total Downloads: 8571806
Recent Additions

Downloads
24 May Mario Kart - Super C... by: MrBobDobolina in: Game Boy Advance
13 May Sparkster by: Rockstar1983 in: Genesis (Mega Drive)
14 Mar LEGO Star Wars - The... by: MiloScat in: Wii
14 Mar Superman by: superfly in: Nintendo 64
14 Mar Lost Vikings 2 by: superfly in: Super NES (Super Famicom)
14 Mar Chrono Trigger by: MiloScat in: Nintendo DS
14 Mar Scribblenauts by: MiloScat in: Nintendo DS
14 Mar Final Fantasy IV by: Testament in: Nintendo DS
29 Jan Harvest Moon DS by: superfly in: Nintendo DS
23 Jan Brave Story - New Tr... by: Arhkaos in: PSP
Sites we like
 News::Bethesda adds their games to list of "banned" documentation
That's right, it came up in direct communication between myself and the Bethesda Softworks Community Manager. Although I think it's a terrible disservice to the community and especially fans of their classic games, it's their right to go to absurd lengths to protect their intellectual property.

In the past Bethesda had contacted me to remove our Morrowind docs on threat of legal action. At the time, Morrowind was a new release, and I could understand their concern. However, they didn't mention anything about the docs we had at the time from the older Elder Scrolls games. So I was under the assumption that they were only concerned with their newest properties that were still being sold. Fair enough.

Lots of people have come here looking for Oblivion docs. I had never posted any because of the Morrowind experience. But I always wondered if they would "release" the Morrowind docs now that Oblivion is their newest title. That seemed to be a reasonable way to approach protecting their currently profitable property while still maintaining interest in their older products. It works for id software apparently, since they have released older versions of their Quake games and engines as free open source downloads. Even Bethesda did something similar when they released the first Elder Scrolls game, Arena, as freeware in 2004.

But apparently Bethesda falls into a different camp regarding manuals. After discussion with their Community Manager, they now want all of their docs removed. And by "all" I don't mean current, I mean everything they have ever produced.

So effective immediately, replacementdocs will no longer be posting ANY docs for ANY of Bethesda Softworks' games.

The worst part is the fact that Arena is freeware, and guess what? They want documentation for Arena removed as well. Does that make any sense at all?! I mean, come on! You're giving away the game for free, but you're "protecting" your rights on the manual? How do you expect people to play the game that you're supposedly giving away for free?

I have always said that I will promptly comply with any requests that copyright holders make, but I never said I would like it or do so quietly without speaking my mind.

This marks the first time that any game publisher has requested that we remove documentation for games that are no longer being sold. As I said, it is well within their rights to demand this as owners of the property. However, I don't think they realize how it amounts to a slap in the face to their fan community.

I think the only hope at this point is to spread the news about this as much as possible and get enough of people angry about it that Bethesda retracts their restriction, at least for the out-of-print games.
Read/Post Comment: 8bysleepyonTuesday 01 May 2007 - 08:59:58printer friendly
 

Comments

 
bulletadf
Comments: 6
Registered: 13 Apr 07 : 03:19
\01 May 07 : 11:05

i found Bethesda ridiculous at this point. maybe they consider their campaign setting worth a huge fortune

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


bulletElectric Fungus
Comments: 51
Registered: 31 Oct 05 : 22:23Location: peeking through the blinds
\01 May 07 : 22:00

Funny. They don't seem too offended by having all those scans of their boxes and CD labels on MobyGames. The disc labels in particular are of no legitimate use to anyone. People who sell pirated copies like them though.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
When dealing with liberals, always attribute to malice what would ordinarily be attributed to incompetence.

At the core of liberalism is the spoiled child - miserable, as all spoiled children are, unsatisfied, demanding, ill-disciplined, despotic and useless.


bulletRvB_Private_Caboose
Comments: 1
Registered: 26 May 07 : 14:26
\26 May 07 : 14:36

Ouch... that hurts

Bethesda, why do you have to disappoint me like that?

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
En Taro Adun!
Image: http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y8/PrvtCaboose/Officiallygetacookiev2.jpg
I'm the official ruler of Cookies and all things that make no sense!


bulletOSH
Comments: 2
Registered: 02 Aug 06 : 00:24
\31 May 07 : 11:00

VERY STRANGE...Bethesda, what a stupid Community Manager have you?!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


bulletAnamon
Comments: 8
Registered: 28 Feb 07 : 20:27
\05 Jun 07 : 11:34

Wow, that guy should be fired asap. He's definitely not good for Bethesda's image.

Now everytime you need a Bethesda replacement manual, just contact them directly. Maybe 1000 requests for an Arena manual per month will wake them up.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


bulletCitizenKen
Comments: 1
Registered: 06 Jun 07 : 07:46
\06 Jun 07 : 07:50

That's interesting...because I just joined this community looking for a manual for a Bethesda game.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Citizen Ken


bulletmarques
Comments: 1
Registered: 07 Jun 07 : 05:21
\07 Jun 07 : 05:33

Perhaps the free Arena manual should be renamed to a blatant
-Arena walkthru'- and a copy sent, pronto, to that lousy guy.
oh my...

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


bulletDark Pilot
Comments: 5
Registered: 08 Oct 05 : 00:14
\09 Jun 07 : 10:18

I respect Bethesda for best 3d actions - Terminator-FS and SkyNET. But that decision is stupid.
Give me that manager!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~



You must be logged in to make comments on this site - please log in, or if you are not registered click here to signup
 Sponsored Links
 
 Chatbox
 
You must be logged in to post comments on this site - please either log in or if you are not registered click here to signup


...: perikiz :...
04 Jul 15 : 03:59

Even registered is quota of 3 - be forewarned.http://www.perikiz.com
...: ishmael2u :...
20 Jun 15 : 16:21

I could read all of them. It was like reading a series of sports news headlines.
...: Alastair :...
14 Jun 15 : 15:38

Thanks Ishmael, could you read all of his posts or just the ones that I deleted? (Note that I deleted any of xiaoli's posts that I could read without logging in, though why those particular posts were visible is something I do not understand.)
...: ishmael2u :...
13 Jun 15 : 11:41

Alastair, I was one of the unfortunate ones who could read his posts.
...: Cicciolo :...
13 Jun 15 : 10:36

About time heh. Thanks.
...: sleepy :...
12 Jun 15 : 17:40

xiaoli has been banned
...: Alastair :...
12 Jun 15 : 11:52

Thanks Cicciolo, I just can't understand why xiaoli would want to waste so much of his time posting spam that no-one, barring admin and mods, can read.

We will just have to wait until Sleepy logs in again and hope that he bans at least this spammer.
...: Cicciolo :...
11 Jun 15 : 14:03

I get the REQUIRES message (just like you, i guess)
...: Alastair :...
11 Jun 15 : 11:46

A quick question, can anybody read xiaoli's posts or do you just get '[ REQUIRES ADMIN APPROVAL ]'? (I'm trying to work out why xiaoli bothers.)
...: Cicciolo :...
11 Jun 15 : 08:48

That freak is back, AGAIN. Where's sleepy? He posted a month ago but xiaoli was already there for months.

 Online
 
Guests: 25, Members: 0 ...

most ever online: 337
(Members: 0, Guests: 337) on 06 May 10 : 13:54

Members: 37987
Newest member: ahmad
 RSS Feeds
 
Our news can be syndicated by using these rss feeds.
rss1.0
rss2.0
rdf
  Top


All game documentation is their respective owners, all other content is replacementdocs.com.

Disclaimer: replacementdocs.com does not intend to infringe upon the copyrights of publishers of the documentation listed herein. replacementdocs.com also does not condone software piracy. For more information on our stance on this topic and reasoning behind it, please check our FAQs page.

If you are the copyright holder of anything listed herein and still want your documentation removed after reading the FAQ page, please send feedback and it will be removed.